ABC vs TiVo: Can’t we all get along?

November 2, 2005

Dear Stupid Television Programmers:

Stop it. Just stop it.

I’ve had enough of your stupid games with the start and end times to your shows.

I missed an episode of “Commander in Chief” last week. It was on from 9:00 - 10:01.

“Why would a show be on until 10:01?” you ask.

Simple: the Stupid Television Programmers think that if you are watching their network at 10:01 that means that you are not watching another network. Which means that if you are watching ABC from 9:00 p.m. until 10:01 p.m. they hope to get you to watch from 10:01 p.m. until 11 (by which point they will have run ads at the bottom of the screen for the news and hope to have you hooked in for that too).

TNT has done this for years, they started/ended at :05 past the hour. Maybe because they were hoping to catch people who were flipping through channels at the top of the hour.

But now several networks (ABC especially) are doing this thing where they will run shows for 59 minutes or 1hour and 1 minute.

Well they’ve now screwed themselves with all the TiVo owners in the world (and other PVR owners as well).

For those of you who aren’t familiar, the beauty of TiVo is that I don’t it to record based on channel and night. For example, last year “Alias” was on at 9 p.m. on Wednesdays after “Lost”.

I didn’t set the TiVo to record Wednesday nights at 9:00 p.m., I said “Record new episodes of Alias” and the TiVo did the rest. So on weeks when Alias wasn’t on, it didn’t record. If Alias was on but was a repeat, it didn’t record. Now this season Alias has moved to 8:00 p.m. on Thursday, and I didn’t have to do anything, and I didn’t even have to know when the new season was starting, the TiVo took care of it for me.

The only problem comes when two shows overlap (i.e. what if I want to record two shows and they are both on at the same time?). For that TiVo will warn you if it sees conflicts when you first setup a “Season Pass” (their name for when you tell the TiVo to record all the episodes of a given show), but if there aren’t any conflicts, it will just schedule it. If conflicts arise later, it will set priority based on which Season Pass is ranked higher. You can set the rank yourself, but if you don’t, newer shows are given a lower priority than older shows. This makes sense to me, if I have been watching a show for a long time and a new show comes along and conflicts, it’s a safe bet that I want to watch the old favorite over the new.

So here’s what happened:

“Commander in Chief” (CIC) was scheduled from 9:00 - 10:01 p.m. “Nip/Tuck” was scheduled from 10:00 p.m. to 11:00 p.m.

Since CIC is a new show, it had a lower priority. It didn’t get recorded.

WOW! Talk about backfiring, eh? Here you were trying to lure people to stay on ABC from 10:01 p.m. until 11:00 p.m. and you ended up losing a bunch of TiVo and other PVR users.

Dear TiVo:

You rarely disappoint me, but tonight was a big let-down (and I’m not the only one who thinks so).

1) You ought to have told me that a show wasn’t going to be recorded due to a conflict. We see each other every day, you couldn’t put up a little message: “Hey, a conflict has been found and I think you’d rather watch Nip/Tuck than CIC, but I just wanted to let you know” — is that asking so much?

2) Also, Nip/Tuck is on several times a week. CIC is not. Wouldn’t it have made more sense to record Nip/Tuck on another night? You know I’m like 4 weeks behind in watching it anyway, so it’s not like it was going to bother me if I had to wait a day or so.

3) At the very least, you should have recorded the first hour of CIC. Yeah I would have been upset if I missed something important in the last minute of the show, but probably it was just a “Next week on CIC…” which you know I never watch anyway.

Dear Stupid Television Programmers:

Why is CIC only on once a week? You may have heard about these new fangled VCR things that people have? Yeah, so maybe you’d consider replaying some of your top shows at like 5 a.m. on Thursday? I know, that would break out of the box you want us to be in where we sit and watch on your schedule, but our lives don’t work that way, and the sooner you realize it, the better we’ll get along. F/X has figured this out, why haven’t you? Could it be because you’re old and slow to change? Life is change. Embrace it.

blog comments powered by Disqus

Previous post:

Next post: